engine feed: the arts engine staff blog
Log in [?]

The entries below are not necessarily representative of the views of MediaRights, a project of Arts Engine, Inc.

The Doc Shortlist Drama

Angela

Recently, the shortlist for Best Documentary Oscar nominations were announced and there were many people with some strong feelings about it.

AJ Schnack, whose film, Kurt Cobain About A Son qualified under the Academy’s rules but was not selected, wrote a lengthy article. This point was particularly interesting:

Should we prefer a competent, conventionally styled film to one that swings for the fences, one whose highs hit us in unexpected ways, even if it occasionally falters in its risk-taking? The Academy and the IDA have chosen to stand on the side of conventional and competent.
Even more importantly, should we favor a film’s message over its craft? Here again, both the Academy and the IDA have answered resoundingly. Craft always comes in last.

Tricia Regan, whose film, Autism: The Musical, was on the shortlist this year, had this to say:

It truly is an honor just to be short-listed. And I agree, there are many great docs out there that did not make the short list, but they have been well recognized in other arenas, picking up awards all along the way. There is so much luck in all of this, but in the end, there are a lot of great docs, so getting into Sundance, winning an award, getting short-listed or nominated or even winning an Oscar, comes down to the individuals doing the voting and their particular tastes, and whatever politics exist within that voting structure.

Many other people are talking about this.

I looked at the shortlist and had not heard of many of these films. (And I am someone who sees a decent amount of docs.) I was disappointed that The King of Kong, my absolute favorite movie of this year, was not on this list. I have a hard time believing that all of these films are better. (Yes I know this list is subjective.) And I do believe that the storyline of the film — a battle to be the greatest Donkey Kong player in the world — stopped it from being selected. You can’t nominate a film like that for the Academy Award. Well, I think you can but the “powers that be” obviously disagree.

Thank goodness the qualification requirements have changed for next year. Eliminating the multiple-city rollout will create a bit more of a level playing field. I am not naive enough to believe that this process will magically become fair but it will be better. Too much of this has to do with the quality of your publicity or the size of your marketing budget. I wish more of it had to do with the quality of your film.

Comments

Share Your Thoughts

Please log in to leave a comment.

read the latest | read the archives

our bloggers

Katy Chevigny
position: Executive Director
one thing to know about me: I am a native New Yorker but I did live in Chicago for seven years.
read posts by Katy


Enrico Cullen
position: Director, Development & External Affairs
one thing to know about me: I've never broken a bone.
read posts by Enrico


Beth Davenport
position: Producer
one thing to know about me: I am remarkably good at impersonating tall people.
read posts by Beth


Felix Endara
position: Filmmaker Services Coordinator
one thing to know about me: If I were a sandwich, I'd be a BLT because of the infinite ways it can be customized.
read posts by Felix


Jennifer Gallardo
position: Director of Technology & Online Programs
one thing to know about me: I get stir crazy if I go too long without adequate sleep or chocolate.
read posts by Jennifer



Mary Myers
position: Associate, Development & External Affairs
one thing to know about me: I was conceived on an aircraft carrier.
read posts by Mary


Laimah Osman
position: Web Developer
one thing to know about me: The best pictures of me are the ones that I have taken myself.
read posts by Laimah


Jolene Pinder
position: Associate Producer
one thing to know about me: I keep a small library of songs that incorporate my name. I wish I could claim a personal connection to at least one of 'em.
read posts by Jolene


Intern Team
position: Intern
one thing to know about us: We run the show.
read posts by the interns


Kasmore Rhedrick
position: Web Editor
one thing to know about me: I have a knack for falling asleep in odd places.
read posts by Kasmore


Angela Tucker
position: Director of Production
one thing to know about me: I was named after Angela Davis. She and I have three key things in common: We are both African-American, six feet tall, and have big hair.
read posts by Angela


browse archives